3ami - computer monitoring

IT Security Solution Specialists

The Legalities of Workplace Monitoring

"Is it legal for me to monitor my employee’s activity in the workplace?" In the UK, this is the first question we are always asked by business owners and managers interested in MAS and wishing to protect their business and themselves (vicarious liability) through the potentially inappropriate or even criminal and illegal behaviour of their employees in the workplace.

To answer this and other critical questions important to both the Employer and the Employee, we have teamed up with leading UK Personnel & Employment Law Consultancy - Peninsula.

email: legal@3ami.com


Established since 1983, Peninsula provide their 17,500 clients, throughout the UK, with Personnel and Employment Law and Health and Safety Consultancy.

Peninsula have grown due to their commitment to customer care and by tailoring their unique Services, including Employment Tribunal Services, Corporate Solutions for larger corporate clients, Tailored Training and informative Seminars.

 

Peninsula Business Services


Questions answered by Mike Huss, Peninsula's Senior Employment Law Specialist

Questions from the employer:
  1. Is it legal for me to monitor my employee’s activity in the workplace?
  2. What do I have to do to make it legal?
  3. What are the benefits to me?
Questions from the employee:
  1. Does workplace monitoring infringe my rights?
  2. What do I need to know about workplace monitoring?

Workplace Monitoring

Questions from the Employer:

    1. Is it legal for me to monitor my employee’s activity in the workplace?

      Peninsula answer:

        Not only is it legal, it could be argued that it is mandatory. 

        If you do not monitor:

        • you do not know if they are doing any work;
        • you do not know the quality or quantity;
        • you do not know if they are visiting inappropriate internet sites;
        • you do not know if they are forwarding downloads from inappropriate sites to other staff who might feel harassed or threatened by them; and
        • you do not know if they are sending harassing bullying or downright disgusting e-mails to other staff, customers, suppliers or people outside of work.

        Back to Top

    2. What do I have to do to make it legal?

      Peninsula answer:

        Staff should be made aware, at induction and reminded subsequently at intervals, that it is your policy to monitor, that you in fact do so and will take action against transgressors.

        The detail should be spelt out in contracts of employment and the employee handbook as appropriate.

        If you do not have such terms in your current contracts then you will need to introduce them. Consult with all your staff explaining why you need to do this. Listen to any objections – encompass them if you can, but it is your responsibility. If necessary dismiss (invalid) objections by, if you cannot persuade the individual(s) to accept the changes, giving them their notice, in writing (complying with the Statutory Disputes Resolutions Procedures), that the employment is terminated and offering them the alternative contract containing exactly the same terms and conditions as before but including the additional terms relating to monitoring.

        Back to Top

    3. What are the benefits to me?

      Peninsula answer:

        Fewer problems regarding low performance, both quality and quantity, less (hopefully none) misbehaviour with the internet and e-mails and a smoother disciplinary or capability progression with added certainty of winning any Tribunal should one happen along.

        Back to Top


Questions from the employee:

    1. Does workplace monitoring infringe my rights?

      Peninsula answer:

        No – it enhances them. The Employment Rights Act 1996, the Data Protection Act 1998, the Human Rights Act 1998 (which does not apply to private employers anyway) the Telecommunications (Lawful Business Practice) (Interception of Communications) Regulations 2000 allow, and require that employees use of telecommunications equipment can and should be monitored to prevent abuses of employees by their employer and other employees.

        Nothing in all the regulations gives an employee the right to use the employer’s equipment for personal use but if an employer does allow the, for example, taking of private telephone calls in an emergency, those calls should not be monitored or listened to. However all business “transactions” can and should be monitored to prevent harassment, bullying or abuse of employees by another. Staff should be made aware that such monitoring occurs and what will happen if someone does disobey the rules.

        Back to Top

    2. What do I need to know about workplace monitoring?

        Peninsula answer:

          That it:

          • happens;
          • what is and is not acceptable; and
          • what happens if the rules are infringed



Tel: +44(0)1695 738003

email legal@3ami.com